{
 "name": "Upstream scores",
 "edition": "2026-11-10",
 "read_date": "2026-11-10",
 "source": "https://datalineagecompare.com/datasets/",
 "license": "CC BY 4.0",
 "cite": "Upstream, The Lineage Depth Matrix and Upstream scores, edition of 10 Nov 2026, datalineagecompare.com/datasets/, CC BY 4.0.",
 "description": "Blind scores 0 to 10 for 16 data lineage tools on seven weighted criteria, with the weight, the reason and the fact ids, and the total on 0 to 100.",
 "rows": [
  {
   "rank": 1,
   "tool": "Euno",
   "slug": "euno",
   "criterion": "Depth of lineage",
   "weight": 25,
   "score": 7,
   "why": "Column lineage to BI dashboards and metrics with SQL analysis of workbook logic.",
   "fact_ids": "euno-01; euno-02; euno-03; euno-04; euno-05; euno-06",
   "total": "67.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 1,
   "tool": "Euno",
   "slug": "euno",
   "criterion": "Lineage that carries meaning",
   "weight": 20,
   "score": 7,
   "why": "Labels and classifications propagate along lineage into BI fields.",
   "fact_ids": "euno-07; euno-08; euno-09; euno-10; euno-11",
   "total": "67.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 1,
   "tool": "Euno",
   "slug": "euno",
   "criterion": "Served to agents",
   "weight": 20,
   "score": 7,
   "why": "Persona-scoped context over MCP, SDK and API with OAuth.",
   "fact_ids": "euno-12; euno-13; euno-14; euno-15; euno-16",
   "total": "67.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 1,
   "tool": "Euno",
   "slug": "euno",
   "criterion": "Coverage of the stack",
   "weight": 15,
   "score": 7,
   "why": "Named warehouses, transformation, BI, security and identity sources.",
   "fact_ids": "euno-17; euno-18; euno-19; euno-20; euno-21; euno-22",
   "total": "67.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 1,
   "tool": "Euno",
   "slug": "euno",
   "criterion": "Stays current without work",
   "weight": 10,
   "score": 6,
   "why": "Daily default sync, continuous rebuild, dbt run artifacts and trigger URL.",
   "fact_ids": "euno-23; euno-24; euno-25; euno-26",
   "total": "67.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 1,
   "tool": "Euno",
   "slug": "euno",
   "criterion": "Safe to deploy",
   "weight": 5,
   "score": 6,
   "why": "Metadata-only, audit log and per-call permission checks; certifications not found.",
   "fact_ids": "euno-27; euno-28; euno-29; euno-30; euno-31; euno-33",
   "total": "67.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 1,
   "tool": "Euno",
   "slug": "euno",
   "criterion": "Price transparency",
   "weight": 5,
   "score": 4,
   "why": "Pricing model and tiers published; no dollars.",
   "fact_ids": "euno-34; euno-35; euno-36; euno-37",
   "total": "67.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 2,
   "tool": "DataHub",
   "slug": "datahub",
   "criterion": "Depth of lineage",
   "weight": 25,
   "score": 6,
   "why": "SQL-parser column lineage, chart-to-dashboard edges and MCP query paths; no metric lineage found.",
   "fact_ids": "datahub-01; datahub-02; datahub-03; datahub-04; datahub-05; datahub-06",
   "total": "62.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 2,
   "tool": "DataHub",
   "slug": "datahub",
   "criterion": "Lineage that carries meaning",
   "weight": 20,
   "score": 6,
   "why": "Description and glossary term propagation along column lineage, the latter in beta.",
   "fact_ids": "datahub-07; datahub-08; datahub-09",
   "total": "62.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 2,
   "tool": "DataHub",
   "slug": "datahub",
   "criterion": "Served to agents",
   "weight": 20,
   "score": 8,
   "why": "Per-user token MCP with lineage and custom scoped servers; repo and PyPI release observed.",
   "fact_ids": "datahub-10; datahub-11; datahub-13; datahub-12; datahub-19",
   "total": "62.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 2,
   "tool": "DataHub",
   "slug": "datahub",
   "criterion": "Coverage of the stack",
   "weight": 15,
   "score": 6,
   "why": "Named warehouses, dbt, BI and open lineage ingestion; integration count adds little; no security tools named.",
   "fact_ids": "datahub-14; datahub-15; datahub-16",
   "total": "62.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 2,
   "tool": "DataHub",
   "slug": "datahub",
   "criterion": "Stays current without work",
   "weight": 10,
   "score": 6,
   "why": "Automatic extraction; manual edits may be overwritten.",
   "fact_ids": "datahub-17; datahub-18",
   "total": "62.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 2,
   "tool": "DataHub",
   "slug": "datahub",
   "criterion": "Safe to deploy",
   "weight": 5,
   "score": 4,
   "why": "Audit events API and read-only hints; certifications not found.",
   "fact_ids": "datahub-20; datahub-21; datahub-22",
   "total": "62.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 2,
   "tool": "DataHub",
   "slug": "datahub",
   "criterion": "Price transparency",
   "weight": 5,
   "score": 5,
   "why": "Open-source edition free under Apache 2.0; no Cloud price list found.",
   "fact_ids": "datahub-15; datahub-23",
   "total": "62.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 3,
   "tool": "Secoda",
   "slug": "secoda",
   "criterion": "Depth of lineage",
   "weight": 25,
   "score": 6,
   "why": "Column lineage to Looker/Tableau fields; Power BI limits; metrics only as imported terms.",
   "fact_ids": "secoda-01; secoda-02; secoda-03; secoda-04; secoda-23",
   "total": "61.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 3,
   "tool": "Secoda",
   "slug": "secoda",
   "criterion": "Lineage that carries meaning",
   "weight": 20,
   "score": 6,
   "why": "Owner and tag propagation by lineage and rule-based automations.",
   "fact_ids": "secoda-05; secoda-06",
   "total": "61.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 3,
   "tool": "Secoda",
   "slug": "secoda",
   "criterion": "Served to agents",
   "weight": 20,
   "score": 7,
   "why": "MCP with lineage and glossary respecting workspace and team permissions.",
   "fact_ids": "secoda-07; secoda-08; secoda-09",
   "total": "61.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 3,
   "tool": "Secoda",
   "slug": "secoda",
   "criterion": "Coverage of the stack",
   "weight": 15,
   "score": 6,
   "why": "Named warehouses, BI and dbt tools; no security tools named.",
   "fact_ids": "secoda-10; secoda-11; secoda-12",
   "total": "61.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 3,
   "tool": "Secoda",
   "slug": "secoda",
   "criterion": "Stays current without work",
   "weight": 10,
   "score": 6,
   "why": "All lineage automated; depends on sync order.",
   "fact_ids": "secoda-13; secoda-14",
   "total": "61.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 3,
   "tool": "Secoda",
   "slug": "secoda",
   "criterion": "Safe to deploy",
   "weight": 5,
   "score": 7,
   "why": "Read-only grants, SOC 2, metadata-only to LLM, SIEM on Enterprise.",
   "fact_ids": "secoda-15; secoda-16; secoda-17; secoda-18",
   "total": "61.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 3,
   "tool": "Secoda",
   "slug": "secoda",
   "criterion": "Price transparency",
   "weight": 5,
   "score": 4,
   "why": "Three tiers with features but no dollars.",
   "fact_ids": "secoda-19",
   "total": "61.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 4,
   "tool": "Atlan",
   "slug": "atlan",
   "criterion": "Depth of lineage",
   "weight": 25,
   "score": 6,
   "why": "SQL-parsed column lineage with documented limits (joins/filters excluded) and no metric lineage found.",
   "fact_ids": "atlan-01; atlan-02; atlan-03; atlan-04; atlan-05; atlan-06",
   "total": "58.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 4,
   "tool": "Atlan",
   "slug": "atlan",
   "criterion": "Lineage that carries meaning",
   "weight": 20,
   "score": 6,
   "why": "Propagator pushes owners, tags, certificates downstream, but tag propagation is off by default.",
   "fact_ids": "atlan-07; atlan-08; atlan-09; atlan-10",
   "total": "58.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 4,
   "tool": "Atlan",
   "slug": "atlan",
   "criterion": "Served to agents",
   "weight": 20,
   "score": 7,
   "why": "Hosted MCP with per-user OAuth and persona scoping over lineage and glossary; vendor only.",
   "fact_ids": "atlan-11; atlan-12; atlan-13; atlan-14",
   "total": "58.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 4,
   "tool": "Atlan",
   "slug": "atlan",
   "criterion": "Coverage of the stack",
   "weight": 15,
   "score": 6,
   "why": "Named transformation, BI and warehouse sources with documented gaps; no security tools named.",
   "fact_ids": "atlan-15; atlan-16; atlan-17",
   "total": "58.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 4,
   "tool": "Atlan",
   "slug": "atlan",
   "criterion": "Stays current without work",
   "weight": 10,
   "score": 6,
   "why": "Scheduled crawls with incremental updates and real-time via open lineage events.",
   "fact_ids": "atlan-18; atlan-19",
   "total": "58.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 4,
   "tool": "Atlan",
   "slug": "atlan",
   "criterion": "Safe to deploy",
   "weight": 5,
   "score": 5,
   "why": "Permission-respecting read-only MCP and audit table; certifications not found.",
   "fact_ids": "atlan-20; atlan-21; atlan-22; atlan-23",
   "total": "58.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 4,
   "tool": "Atlan",
   "slug": "atlan",
   "criterion": "Price transparency",
   "weight": 5,
   "score": 0,
   "why": "None found on 2026-11-10: no prices or pricing model.",
   "fact_ids": "atlan-24",
   "total": "58.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 5,
   "tool": "Foundational",
   "slug": "foundational",
   "criterion": "Depth of lineage",
   "weight": 25,
   "score": 6,
   "why": "Code-parsed column lineage incl. PySpark and BI DAX/LookML; no metric lineage found.",
   "fact_ids": "foundational-01; foundational-02; foundational-03; foundational-04; foundational-05; foundational-23",
   "total": "58.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 5,
   "tool": "Foundational",
   "slug": "foundational",
   "criterion": "Lineage that carries meaning",
   "weight": 20,
   "score": 4,
   "why": "Docs, owners and tags shown; no downstream propagation found.",
   "fact_ids": "foundational-06; foundational-07",
   "total": "58.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 5,
   "tool": "Foundational",
   "slug": "foundational",
   "criterion": "Served to agents",
   "weight": 20,
   "score": 6,
   "why": "Remote MCP tied to user account, many client guides, public API.",
   "fact_ids": "foundational-08; foundational-09; foundational-10",
   "total": "58.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 5,
   "tool": "Foundational",
   "slug": "foundational",
   "criterion": "Coverage of the stack",
   "weight": 15,
   "score": 7,
   "why": "Named source control, languages, ETL, warehouses and BI.",
   "fact_ids": "foundational-11; foundational-12; foundational-13",
   "total": "58.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 5,
   "tool": "Foundational",
   "slug": "foundational",
   "criterion": "Stays current without work",
   "weight": 10,
   "score": 7,
   "why": "Pull-request webhooks and scheduled scans with versioned graph.",
   "fact_ids": "foundational-14; foundational-15",
   "total": "58.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 5,
   "tool": "Foundational",
   "slug": "foundational",
   "criterion": "Safe to deploy",
   "weight": 5,
   "score": 7,
   "why": "Metadata-first, SOC 2 Type II, token roles and auditing.",
   "fact_ids": "foundational-16; foundational-17; foundational-18",
   "total": "58.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 5,
   "tool": "Foundational",
   "slug": "foundational",
   "criterion": "Price transparency",
   "weight": 5,
   "score": 4,
   "why": "Pricing by tracked objects described; no dollars.",
   "fact_ids": "foundational-19",
   "total": "58.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 6,
   "tool": "Coalesce Catalog",
   "slug": "coalesce-catalog",
   "criterion": "Depth of lineage",
   "weight": 25,
   "score": 6,
   "why": "Column lineage from query history with named BI field links; Sigma/Omni asset-level only.",
   "fact_ids": "coalesce-catalog-01; coalesce-catalog-02; coalesce-catalog-03; coalesce-catalog-04",
   "total": "57.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 6,
   "tool": "Coalesce Catalog",
   "slug": "coalesce-catalog",
   "criterion": "Lineage that carries meaning",
   "weight": 20,
   "score": 5,
   "why": "Description copy along lineage with narrow conditions; glossary and bulk edits.",
   "fact_ids": "coalesce-catalog-05; coalesce-catalog-06; coalesce-catalog-07",
   "total": "57.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 6,
   "tool": "Coalesce Catalog",
   "slug": "coalesce-catalog",
   "criterion": "Served to agents",
   "weight": 20,
   "score": 6,
   "why": "Per-user OAuth MCP (16 tools, off by default), GraphQL API and scoped tokens.",
   "fact_ids": "coalesce-catalog-08; coalesce-catalog-09; coalesce-catalog-10",
   "total": "57.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 6,
   "tool": "Coalesce Catalog",
   "slug": "coalesce-catalog",
   "criterion": "Coverage of the stack",
   "weight": 15,
   "score": 6,
   "why": "Named BI, warehouse, dbt and orchestration tools.",
   "fact_ids": "coalesce-catalog-11; coalesce-catalog-12",
   "total": "57.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 6,
   "tool": "Coalesce Catalog",
   "slug": "coalesce-catalog",
   "criterion": "Stays current without work",
   "weight": 10,
   "score": 5,
   "why": "Rolling 30-day SQL window, up to 48h BI sync, dbt sync on push.",
   "fact_ids": "coalesce-catalog-13; coalesce-catalog-14; coalesce-catalog-15",
   "total": "57.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 6,
   "tool": "Coalesce Catalog",
   "slug": "coalesce-catalog",
   "criterion": "Safe to deploy",
   "weight": 5,
   "score": 5,
   "why": "Scoped tokens and SOC 2 Type 2 at parent level; no metadata-only statement.",
   "fact_ids": "coalesce-catalog-16; coalesce-catalog-17; coalesce-catalog-18",
   "total": "57.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 6,
   "tool": "Coalesce Catalog",
   "slug": "coalesce-catalog",
   "criterion": "Price transparency",
   "weight": 5,
   "score": 7,
   "why": "Starter published at $150 per user per month, Enterprise custom.",
   "fact_ids": "coalesce-catalog-19",
   "total": "57.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 7,
   "tool": "Collibra",
   "slug": "collibra",
   "criterion": "Depth of lineage",
   "weight": 25,
   "score": 6,
   "why": "Table/column/report lineage with code and MCP measure tracing; documented exclusions.",
   "fact_ids": "collibra-01; collibra-02; collibra-03; collibra-04; collibra-05; collibra-06",
   "total": "56.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 7,
   "tool": "Collibra",
   "slug": "collibra",
   "criterion": "Lineage that carries meaning",
   "weight": 20,
   "score": 4,
   "why": "No lineage propagation mechanism named; MCP returns glossary and classification tools.",
   "fact_ids": "collibra-07; collibra-08",
   "total": "56.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 7,
   "tool": "Collibra",
   "slug": "collibra",
   "criterion": "Served to agents",
   "weight": 20,
   "score": 8,
   "why": "MCP lineage tools with OAuth scopes and permission errors; GitHub repo and release observed.",
   "fact_ids": "collibra-09; collibra-10; collibra-11; collibra-18",
   "total": "56.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 7,
   "tool": "Collibra",
   "slug": "collibra",
   "criterion": "Coverage of the stack",
   "weight": 15,
   "score": 6,
   "why": "Named warehouses, ETL and BI tools.",
   "fact_ids": "collibra-12; collibra-13; collibra-14",
   "total": "56.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 7,
   "tool": "Collibra",
   "slug": "collibra",
   "criterion": "Stays current without work",
   "weight": 10,
   "score": 4,
   "why": "Harvester retired; per-source manual sync trigger from Edge; automated ingestion for open lineage.",
   "fact_ids": "collibra-15; collibra-16; collibra-17",
   "total": "56.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 7,
   "tool": "Collibra",
   "slug": "collibra",
   "criterion": "Safe to deploy",
   "weight": 5,
   "score": 6,
   "why": "Existing permissions respected; trust center lists many certifications.",
   "fact_ids": "collibra-19; collibra-20",
   "total": "56.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 7,
   "tool": "Collibra",
   "slug": "collibra",
   "criterion": "Price transparency",
   "weight": 5,
   "score": 3,
   "why": "Pricing model partly described (units for MCP tools); no platform price list.",
   "fact_ids": "collibra-21; collibra-22",
   "total": "56.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 8,
   "tool": "Alation",
   "slug": "alation",
   "criterion": "Depth of lineage",
   "weight": 25,
   "score": 5,
   "why": "Column lineage and BI extraction claimed by vendor; no metric lineage found.",
   "fact_ids": "alation-01; alation-03; alation-04; alation-05",
   "total": "55.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 8,
   "tool": "Alation",
   "slug": "alation",
   "criterion": "Lineage that carries meaning",
   "weight": 20,
   "score": 5,
   "why": "Nodes carry owners and definitions; no tag propagation along lineage found.",
   "fact_ids": "alation-06; alation-07; alation-08",
   "total": "55.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 8,
   "tool": "Alation",
   "slug": "alation",
   "criterion": "Served to agents",
   "weight": 20,
   "score": 8,
   "why": "Remote MCP filters tools by user; SDK repo and PyPI release observed.",
   "fact_ids": "alation-09; alation-10; alation-16",
   "total": "55.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 8,
   "tool": "Alation",
   "slug": "alation",
   "criterion": "Coverage of the stack",
   "weight": 15,
   "score": 6,
   "why": "Named warehouses, BI, dbt and Spark/Trino sources, vendor claim only.",
   "fact_ids": "alation-12; alation-13; alation-14",
   "total": "55.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 8,
   "tool": "Alation",
   "slug": "alation",
   "criterion": "Stays current without work",
   "weight": 10,
   "score": 5,
   "why": "Version-aware lineage closes stale links automatically; little else on freshness.",
   "fact_ids": "alation-15",
   "total": "55.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 8,
   "tool": "Alation",
   "slug": "alation",
   "criterion": "Safe to deploy",
   "weight": 5,
   "score": 5,
   "why": "SOC 2 Type 2 and ISO 27001 claimed; MCP needs client credentials; no metadata-only statement.",
   "fact_ids": "alation-17; alation-18",
   "total": "55.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 8,
   "tool": "Alation",
   "slug": "alation",
   "criterion": "Price transparency",
   "weight": 5,
   "score": 0,
   "why": "None found on 2026-11-10: pricing page is a contact form.",
   "fact_ids": "alation-19",
   "total": "55.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 9,
   "tool": "dbt",
   "slug": "dbt",
   "criterion": "Depth of lineage",
   "weight": 25,
   "score": 6,
   "why": "Column lineage from SQL parsing, select-only, BI via dashboard-level exposures.",
   "fact_ids": "dbt-01; dbt-02; dbt-03; dbt-04; dbt-05; dbt-06",
   "total": "54.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 9,
   "tool": "dbt",
   "slug": "dbt",
   "criterion": "Lineage that carries meaning",
   "weight": 20,
   "score": 5,
   "why": "Descriptions inherit through passthrough columns; exposures recorded.",
   "fact_ids": "dbt-08; dbt-09; dbt-10",
   "total": "54.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 9,
   "tool": "dbt",
   "slug": "dbt",
   "criterion": "Served to agents",
   "weight": 20,
   "score": 6,
   "why": "Governed MCP for lineage, metrics, freshness; self-hosted or remote.",
   "fact_ids": "dbt-11; dbt-12; dbt-13",
   "total": "54.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 9,
   "tool": "dbt",
   "slug": "dbt",
   "criterion": "Coverage of the stack",
   "weight": 15,
   "score": 3,
   "why": "Coverage limited to its own project resources; Tableau is the only other named system, at dashboard level.",
   "fact_ids": "dbt-14; dbt-15; dbt-16",
   "total": "54.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 9,
   "tool": "dbt",
   "slug": "dbt",
   "criterion": "Stays current without work",
   "weight": 10,
   "score": 6,
   "why": "Catalog updates after each production run; CI jobs do not update.",
   "fact_ids": "dbt-17; dbt-18",
   "total": "54.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 9,
   "tool": "dbt",
   "slug": "dbt",
   "criterion": "Safe to deploy",
   "weight": 5,
   "score": 6,
   "why": "Read-only MCP, ISO 42001 and SOC 2 Type II listed.",
   "fact_ids": "dbt-19; dbt-20; dbt-21",
   "total": "54.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 9,
   "tool": "dbt",
   "slug": "dbt",
   "criterion": "Price transparency",
   "weight": 5,
   "score": 7,
   "why": "Starter $100 per user per month and free Developer plan.",
   "fact_ids": "dbt-22; dbt-23",
   "total": "54.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 10,
   "tool": "Snowflake",
   "slug": "snowflake",
   "criterion": "Depth of lineage",
   "weight": 25,
   "score": 5,
   "why": "Column lineage from query history with exclusions; none for semantic views.",
   "fact_ids": "snowflake-01; snowflake-02; snowflake-03; snowflake-04; snowflake-05; snowflake-06; snowflake-07",
   "total": "51.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 10,
   "tool": "Snowflake",
   "slug": "snowflake",
   "criterion": "Lineage that carries meaning",
   "weight": 20,
   "score": 6,
   "why": "Tags inherit and can propagate; lineage tab flags tag gaps.",
   "fact_ids": "snowflake-08; snowflake-09; snowflake-10",
   "total": "51.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 10,
   "tool": "Snowflake",
   "slug": "snowflake",
   "criterion": "Served to agents",
   "weight": 20,
   "score": 5,
   "why": "Managed MCP with role-based access and policy enforcement.",
   "fact_ids": "snowflake-11; snowflake-12",
   "total": "51.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 10,
   "tool": "Snowflake",
   "slug": "snowflake",
   "criterion": "Coverage of the stack",
   "weight": 15,
   "score": 4,
   "why": "Native scope plus preview connectors and open lineage events; limits on shared databases.",
   "fact_ids": "snowflake-13; snowflake-14; snowflake-15",
   "total": "51.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 10,
   "tool": "Snowflake",
   "slug": "snowflake",
   "criterion": "Stays current without work",
   "weight": 10,
   "score": 6,
   "why": "Built automatically from query history, one-year retention.",
   "fact_ids": "snowflake-16; snowflake-17",
   "total": "51.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 10,
   "tool": "Snowflake",
   "slug": "snowflake",
   "criterion": "Safe to deploy",
   "weight": 5,
   "score": 6,
   "why": "Lineage visibility follows privileges; access history; Enterprise only.",
   "fact_ids": "snowflake-18; snowflake-19; snowflake-20",
   "total": "51.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 10,
   "tool": "Snowflake",
   "slug": "snowflake",
   "criterion": "Price transparency",
   "weight": 5,
   "score": 4,
   "why": "Consumption pricing model; no lineage price.",
   "fact_ids": "snowflake-21; snowflake-22",
   "total": "51.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 11,
   "tool": "SYNQ",
   "slug": "synq",
   "criterion": "Depth of lineage",
   "weight": 25,
   "score": 6,
   "why": "SQL-parsed column lineage into Looker/Tableau with code view and API.",
   "fact_ids": "synq-01; synq-02; synq-03; synq-04",
   "total": "50.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 11,
   "tool": "SYNQ",
   "slug": "synq",
   "criterion": "Lineage that carries meaning",
   "weight": 20,
   "score": 2,
   "why": "Ownership on data products; no propagation found.",
   "fact_ids": "synq-05; synq-21",
   "total": "50.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 11,
   "tool": "SYNQ",
   "slug": "synq",
   "criterion": "Served to agents",
   "weight": 20,
   "score": 6,
   "why": "Remote MCP with role-based consent tiers and lineage tools.",
   "fact_ids": "synq-06; synq-07; synq-08",
   "total": "50.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 11,
   "tool": "SYNQ",
   "slug": "synq",
   "criterion": "Coverage of the stack",
   "weight": 15,
   "score": 5,
   "why": "Named warehouses, BI, dbt and orchestration tools.",
   "fact_ids": "synq-09; synq-10; synq-11",
   "total": "50.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 11,
   "tool": "SYNQ",
   "slug": "synq",
   "criterion": "Stays current without work",
   "weight": 10,
   "score": 6,
   "why": "Lineage extracted several times a day.",
   "fact_ids": "synq-12; synq-13",
   "total": "50.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 11,
   "tool": "SYNQ",
   "slug": "synq",
   "criterion": "Safe to deploy",
   "weight": 5,
   "score": 5,
   "why": "No data persisted, read-only tier; certification not found.",
   "fact_ids": "synq-14; synq-15; synq-16; synq-17",
   "total": "50.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 11,
   "tool": "SYNQ",
   "slug": "synq",
   "criterion": "Price transparency",
   "weight": 5,
   "score": 7,
   "why": "Free Developer plan and Starter at $150 per user per month published (via parent pricing); Enterprise custom.",
   "fact_ids": "synq-18",
   "total": "50.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 12,
   "tool": "Monte Carlo",
   "slug": "monte-carlo",
   "criterion": "Depth of lineage",
   "weight": 25,
   "score": 5,
   "why": "Field lineage from SELECT/other clauses with documented limits; Tableau only for BI fields.",
   "fact_ids": "monte-carlo-05; monte-carlo-06; monte-carlo-07; monte-carlo-08; monte-carlo-09; monte-carlo-10; monte-carlo-11",
   "total": "50.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 12,
   "tool": "Monte Carlo",
   "slug": "monte-carlo",
   "criterion": "Lineage that carries meaning",
   "weight": 20,
   "score": 3,
   "why": "dbt metadata imported; no propagation along column lineage found.",
   "fact_ids": "monte-carlo-12; monte-carlo-13; monte-carlo-14",
   "total": "50.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 12,
   "tool": "Monte Carlo",
   "slug": "monte-carlo",
   "criterion": "Served to agents",
   "weight": 20,
   "score": 6,
   "why": "MCP with lineage tool, OAuth role-based access, read-only header.",
   "fact_ids": "monte-carlo-15; monte-carlo-16; monte-carlo-17; monte-carlo-18; monte-carlo-19",
   "total": "50.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 12,
   "tool": "Monte Carlo",
   "slug": "monte-carlo",
   "criterion": "Coverage of the stack",
   "weight": 15,
   "score": 6,
   "why": "Named warehouses, BI, orchestration and catalog tools.",
   "fact_ids": "monte-carlo-20; monte-carlo-21; monte-carlo-22; monte-carlo-23",
   "total": "50.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 12,
   "tool": "Monte Carlo",
   "slug": "monte-carlo",
   "criterion": "Stays current without work",
   "weight": 10,
   "score": 5,
   "why": "dbt artifacts uploaded per run; up to 24h batch delay.",
   "fact_ids": "monte-carlo-24; monte-carlo-25; monte-carlo-26",
   "total": "50.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 12,
   "tool": "Monte Carlo",
   "slug": "monte-carlo",
   "criterion": "Safe to deploy",
   "weight": 5,
   "score": 7,
   "why": "SOC 2 Type II, ISO 27001 and security features by tier.",
   "fact_ids": "monte-carlo-27; monte-carlo-28",
   "total": "50.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 12,
   "tool": "Monte Carlo",
   "slug": "monte-carlo",
   "criterion": "Price transparency",
   "weight": 5,
   "score": 4,
   "why": "Credit model and tiers published without dollars.",
   "fact_ids": "monte-carlo-29; monte-carlo-30",
   "total": "50.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 13,
   "tool": "Databricks Unity Catalog",
   "slug": "databricks",
   "criterion": "Depth of lineage",
   "weight": 25,
   "score": 5,
   "why": "Automatic column lineage to jobs and dashboards; no transformation expression found.",
   "fact_ids": "databricks-01; databricks-02; databricks-03; databricks-04; databricks-05",
   "total": "47.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 13,
   "tool": "Databricks Unity Catalog",
   "slug": "databricks",
   "criterion": "Lineage that carries meaning",
   "weight": 20,
   "score": 4,
   "why": "Tags inherit to tables not columns; no lineage-based propagation documented.",
   "fact_ids": "databricks-06; databricks-07; databricks-08",
   "total": "47.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 13,
   "tool": "Databricks Unity Catalog",
   "slug": "databricks",
   "criterion": "Served to agents",
   "weight": 20,
   "score": 5,
   "why": "Managed MCP servers governed by catalog grants; little lineage-specific serving.",
   "fact_ids": "databricks-09; databricks-10",
   "total": "47.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 13,
   "tool": "Databricks Unity Catalog",
   "slug": "databricks",
   "criterion": "Coverage of the stack",
   "weight": 15,
   "score": 4,
   "why": "External BI/SaaS assets linkable but lineage limited to registered tables and Spark/SQL.",
   "fact_ids": "databricks-11; databricks-12",
   "total": "47.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 13,
   "tool": "Databricks Unity Catalog",
   "slug": "databricks",
   "criterion": "Stays current without work",
   "weight": 10,
   "score": 6,
   "why": "Automatic capture with 395-day window and indefinite API retention.",
   "fact_ids": "databricks-13; databricks-14",
   "total": "47.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 13,
   "tool": "Databricks Unity Catalog",
   "slug": "databricks",
   "criterion": "Safe to deploy",
   "weight": 5,
   "score": 6,
   "why": "Lineage view needs grants; audit table.",
   "fact_ids": "databricks-15; databricks-16",
   "total": "47.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 13,
   "tool": "Databricks Unity Catalog",
   "slug": "databricks",
   "criterion": "Price transparency",
   "weight": 5,
   "score": 4,
   "why": "Pay-as-you-go model published without dollars; no lineage price found.",
   "fact_ids": "databricks-17; databricks-18",
   "total": "47.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 14,
   "tool": "Select Star",
   "slug": "select-star",
   "criterion": "Depth of lineage",
   "weight": 25,
   "score": 5,
   "why": "Column lineage from query logs and Sigma/Tableau tracing; claims only.",
   "fact_ids": "select-star-05; select-star-06; select-star-07; select-star-08; select-star-09; select-star-10",
   "total": "46.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 14,
   "tool": "Select Star",
   "slug": "select-star",
   "criterion": "Lineage that carries meaning",
   "weight": 20,
   "score": 5,
   "why": "PII tag propagation via automations; MCP exposes glossary and owners.",
   "fact_ids": "select-star-11; select-star-12; select-star-13",
   "total": "46.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 14,
   "tool": "Select Star",
   "slug": "select-star",
   "criterion": "Served to agents",
   "weight": 20,
   "score": 4,
   "why": "MCP with metadata and lineage; scoping not found.",
   "fact_ids": "select-star-14; select-star-15; select-star-16",
   "total": "46.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 14,
   "tool": "Select Star",
   "slug": "select-star",
   "criterion": "Coverage of the stack",
   "weight": 15,
   "score": 6,
   "why": "Named warehouses, BI, dbt and orchestration tools.",
   "fact_ids": "select-star-17; select-star-18; select-star-19",
   "total": "46.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 14,
   "tool": "Select Star",
   "slug": "select-star",
   "criterion": "Stays current without work",
   "weight": 10,
   "score": 4,
   "why": "Automatic indexing; refresh frequency not found.",
   "fact_ids": "select-star-20; select-star-21; select-star-22",
   "total": "46.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 14,
   "tool": "Select Star",
   "slug": "select-star",
   "criterion": "Safe to deploy",
   "weight": 5,
   "score": 6,
   "why": "Metadata-only by default and annual SOC 2 Type II.",
   "fact_ids": "select-star-23; select-star-24; select-star-25",
   "total": "46.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 14,
   "tool": "Select Star",
   "slug": "select-star",
   "criterion": "Price transparency",
   "weight": 5,
   "score": 0,
   "why": "None found on 2026-11-10: no price or model.",
   "fact_ids": "select-star-26",
   "total": "46.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 15,
   "tool": "IBM Manta",
   "slug": "manta",
   "criterion": "Depth of lineage",
   "weight": 25,
   "score": 5,
   "why": "Column and transformation logic claimed; BI field and metric level not found.",
   "fact_ids": "manta-06; manta-07; manta-08; manta-09",
   "total": "40.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 15,
   "tool": "IBM Manta",
   "slug": "manta",
   "criterion": "Lineage that carries meaning",
   "weight": 20,
   "score": 5,
   "why": "Lineage enriched with PII labels, definitions, ownership and policies.",
   "fact_ids": "manta-10; manta-11; manta-12",
   "total": "40.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 15,
   "tool": "IBM Manta",
   "slug": "manta",
   "criterion": "Served to agents",
   "weight": 20,
   "score": 4,
   "why": "MCP and APIs claimed; per-user scoping not found.",
   "fact_ids": "manta-13; manta-14; manta-15; manta-16",
   "total": "40.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 15,
   "tool": "IBM Manta",
   "slug": "manta",
   "criterion": "Coverage of the stack",
   "weight": 15,
   "score": 3,
   "why": "Integration count without names.",
   "fact_ids": "manta-17; manta-18",
   "total": "40.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 15,
   "tool": "IBM Manta",
   "slug": "manta",
   "criterion": "Stays current without work",
   "weight": 10,
   "score": 5,
   "why": "Automated scanning and version history stated.",
   "fact_ids": "manta-19; manta-20",
   "total": "40.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 15,
   "tool": "IBM Manta",
   "slug": "manta",
   "criterion": "Safe to deploy",
   "weight": 5,
   "score": 0,
   "why": "None found on 2026-11-10: no security statements read.",
   "fact_ids": "manta-21",
   "total": "40.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 15,
   "tool": "IBM Manta",
   "slug": "manta",
   "criterion": "Price transparency",
   "weight": 5,
   "score": 1,
   "why": "None found on 2026-11-10 for price; only a free trial offered.",
   "fact_ids": "manta-22; manta-23",
   "total": "40.5",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 16,
   "tool": "OpenLineage and Marquez",
   "slug": "openlineage",
   "criterion": "Depth of lineage",
   "weight": 25,
   "score": 5,
   "why": "Column facet with transformation type, SQL text and dbt/Spark parsing; no BI field or metric level found.",
   "fact_ids": "openlineage-06; openlineage-07; openlineage-08; openlineage-09; openlineage-10; openlineage-11",
   "total": "36.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 16,
   "tool": "OpenLineage and Marquez",
   "slug": "openlineage",
   "criterion": "Lineage that carries meaning",
   "weight": 20,
   "score": 2,
   "why": "Ownership facet only; no propagation found.",
   "fact_ids": "openlineage-12; openlineage-13; openlineage-14",
   "total": "36.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 16,
   "tool": "OpenLineage and Marquez",
   "slug": "openlineage",
   "criterion": "Served to agents",
   "weight": 20,
   "score": 2,
   "why": "Lineage API only; no MCP found on 2026-11-10.",
   "fact_ids": "openlineage-15; openlineage-16",
   "total": "36.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 16,
   "tool": "OpenLineage and Marquez",
   "slug": "openlineage",
   "criterion": "Coverage of the stack",
   "weight": 15,
   "score": 4,
   "why": "Named engines and orchestrators; no BI or security tools.",
   "fact_ids": "openlineage-17; openlineage-18; openlineage-19",
   "total": "36.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 16,
   "tool": "OpenLineage and Marquez",
   "slug": "openlineage",
   "criterion": "Stays current without work",
   "weight": 10,
   "score": 7,
   "why": "Real-time collection from running jobs.",
   "fact_ids": "openlineage-20; openlineage-21; openlineage-22",
   "total": "36.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 16,
   "tool": "OpenLineage and Marquez",
   "slug": "openlineage",
   "criterion": "Safe to deploy",
   "weight": 5,
   "score": 0,
   "why": "None found on 2026-11-10: no security documentation read.",
   "fact_ids": "openlineage-23",
   "total": "36.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  },
  {
   "rank": 16,
   "tool": "OpenLineage and Marquez",
   "slug": "openlineage",
   "criterion": "Price transparency",
   "weight": 5,
   "score": 5,
   "why": "Free under Apache 2.0; no hosted price found.",
   "fact_ids": "openlineage-24",
   "total": "36.0",
   "read": "2026-11-10"
  }
 ]
}